← Back to journal

Time / JAY CLOUD JOURNAL

Mandatory Working Time Recording EU: A Practical Guide

Understand mandatory working time recording EU requirements, Germany’s key rulings, and practical steps for consistent recording across your sites.

Poksundo Team ·

Mandatory Working Time Recording EU: A Practical Guide

Mandatory working time recording EU requirements call for employers to establish a system that records employees’ daily working time, with national rules determining the detailed obligations. The CJEU’s ruling of May 14, 2019, in case C-55/18 established the EU-level framework; Germany’s Federal Labour Court confirmed a recording obligation on September 13, 2022, in decision 1 ABR 22/21. Multinationals should assess each country’s requirements, define consistent recording processes, and connect those processes to reliable workforce data.

This article provides operational guidance, not legal advice. Confirm applicable obligations, exceptions, implementation requirements, and employee-representation issues with counsel in each jurisdiction.

What mandatory working time recording EU requirements mean

Working time recording is more than collecting hours for payroll. A useful system should help employers establish what time was worked, identify incomplete records, and make information available to the people responsible for reviewing it.

The two decisions are important starting points, but they are not a complete implementation specification for every European workplace.

The CJEU ruling: May 14, 2019

In case C-55/18, the Court of Justice of the European Union established that Member States must require employers to set up a system for measuring employees’ daily working time. The ruling describes a system that is objective, reliable, and accessible.

For a multinational, the practical question is therefore not simply whether employees submit a monthly total. It is whether the organisation can produce dependable daily records through a process that meets the applicable national requirements.

Do not treat the judgment as prescribing one software product, one device, or an identical recording workflow across every EU country. Ask counsel how the framework applies to each employing entity and workforce group.

The German decision: September 13, 2022

Germany’s Federal Labour Court confirmed an obligation to record working time in decision 1 ABR 22/21. Employers with German operations should not assume that recording is only a future concern pending a new software mandate or a procurement deadline.

The operational response is to examine the current process: what employees record, how records are reviewed, and whether the organisation can explain how its system works. Counsel should confirm the scope of the obligation and the current requirements for your circumstances.

Start with a country-and-workforce assessment

A common implementation mistake is choosing a time clock before defining the recording policy. A terminal can capture an event, but it cannot resolve an unclear policy about breaks, corrections, travel, or work performed away from a site.

Start with a country-by-country assessment, then map the employee groups within each country. Office employees, production teams, mobile workers, and distributed teams may need different recording methods while following the same governance principles.

Assessment area Question to resolve Operational owner
Legal scope Which entities and employee groups fall within the applicable obligation? HR and local counsel
Recording rules Which events and information must the process capture? HR, payroll, and counsel
Workplace coverage How will office, production, remote, and mobile work be recorded? HR, operations, and IT
Data ownership Which HCM records determine employee identity and organisational assignment? HR systems and IT
Review process Who checks missing entries and approves corrections? Managers and HR
Privacy and access Who may view records, and for which purposes? Privacy, security, and HR
Employee involvement What consultation or participation is required locally? HR, counsel, and employee representatives

The output should be a documented policy and workflow, not merely a list of devices. Where local rules differ, identify the difference explicitly rather than allowing each site to create an undocumented workaround.

Design recording around how people actually work

A recording process that fits a headquarters office may be unsuitable for a production line or a mobile workforce. Adoption depends partly on whether employees can record time at the point where work takes place.

Evaluate recording methods against real scenarios:

  • A production employee starts a shift without regular access to a laptop.
  • An office employee works partly on-site and partly remotely.
  • A mobile employee needs to record time away from a fixed terminal.
  • An employee forgets an entry and needs a documented correction process.

Do not confuse scheduled hours, physical presence, and working time. A shift plan describes expected work. An access event describes movement through a controlled entrance. Neither should automatically be treated as a complete working-time record without an agreed policy and appropriate review.

For shift-based sites, our guide to time and attendance for manufacturing explores the operational setting in more detail.

Make corrections part of the design

Even a well-designed process will encounter missing entries and mistakes. Define who can request a correction, who can approve it, and how the organisation will preserve visibility into changes.

Test ordinary exceptions before rollout. A pilot that captures only straightforward arrivals and departures will tell you little about overnight shifts, forgotten entries, or work away from the main site.

Connect working time to authoritative HCM data

Multinationals often struggle less with recording an event than with keeping employee information consistent across systems. A changed department, new hire, or departure can create discrepancies when each workplace application maintains its own separate employee list.

An HCM-driven approach starts with the workforce record and uses it to inform workplace processes. This gives HR and IT a clearer basis for assigning identities and organisational context, rather than asking every site to recreate those details manually.

jay cloud by Poksundo is a connected layer for Time, Access, Visitor, and Life Safety, driven by HCM data. It has five native HCM connections: SAP, Workday, HiBob, Hubdrive, and Access People. Its setup connects workforce data and derives workplace rules, including shift models, from HR data.

That architecture is relevant when time recording must operate across several locations while staying connected to the organisation’s HR system. It does not remove the need to define local policies or validate the resulting workflows.

For SAP SuccessFactors environments

jay cloud was developed in close cooperation with SAP through the Co-Innovation Program and is native on SAP Business Technology Platform. It has a SAP-certified interface for SuccessFactors Time Tracking Service and Time Sheet.

These are specific integration facts, not a blanket guarantee that every customer configuration meets every working-time requirement. Your evaluation should establish which records move between systems and how the proposed workflow supports your approved policy.

See the SAP partner listing, then use our guides to SAP SuccessFactors time and attendance and SAP SuccessFactors time clock integration to structure implementation questions.

For organisations using another HR platform, the same principle applies: begin with the authoritative workforce record. Our guide to Workday time clock and access integration addresses that architecture for Workday environments.

Evaluate cloud operation, devices, and privacy together

jay cloud supports terminal, mobile, and browser time recording, with employee self-service. It is 100% cloud, with no on-premise infrastructure, and provides central device management with automatic updates and security patches.

The platform is German-built, with Swiss access heritage. Its security architecture includes end-to-end encryption, role-based access controls, and full audit trails; its homepage also identifies GDPR among its security and compliance labels.

These facts can inform procurement, but they should not replace privacy due diligence. A German-built product or a GDPR label does not, by itself, establish that your organisation’s deployment is compliant.

Before selection, ask for evidence addressing:

  • The personal data processed and the purposes for processing it.
  • Administrative roles and access to employee records.
  • Retention, deletion, and correction arrangements.
  • Hosting, contractual terms, and any relevant international transfers.
  • How audit information will support internal review.

Confirm your obligations with privacy specialists and counsel. Also distinguish the cloud service from the physical recording equipment: a cloud architecture does not mean terminals, connectivity, or site-level operating procedures need no attention.

Roll out by proving the process, not just the connection

A successful technical connection is only one milestone. The more useful test is whether employees and managers can follow the agreed process consistently.

Choose a pilot that represents real operational variation. Include a site-based employee group, an office group where relevant, and the managers responsible for reviewing their records. Test hires, organisational changes, missing entries, and departures alongside routine recording.

Set acceptance criteria before testing. For example, require that each pilot employee has the correct identity and assignment, can use the intended recording method, and knows how to report an error. Require reviewers to demonstrate how they identify and resolve incomplete records.

Keep policy ownership separate from technical ownership. HR should own the recording rules, IT should validate the architecture and operation, and counsel should confirm the legal position. Document the decisions so that future sites do not have to reconstruct the reasoning.

Frequently asked questions

Is working time recording mandatory across the EU?

The CJEU’s May 14, 2019 ruling in C-55/18 established that Member States must require employers to implement a system measuring daily working time. Detailed obligations depend on national implementation and the workforce concerned, so confirm the applicable rules with local counsel.

What did Germany’s Federal Labour Court decide in 2022?

The court confirmed a working-time recording obligation on September 13, 2022, in decision 1 ABR 22/21. Employers should assess their current process rather than assume recording can wait; counsel should confirm the scope and requirements for their organisation.

Does every employee need to use a physical time clock?

The cited decisions should not be treated as a universal mandate for one device type. Evaluate methods against applicable requirements and workplace needs; jay cloud supports terminal, mobile, and browser recording.

Can building access records replace time records?

An access event shows entry or exit, not necessarily the complete period worked. Treat access information and working-time information as different records unless an appropriately reviewed process establishes how they should be used together.

Does SAP integration guarantee compliance?

No integration alone guarantees compliance with working-time or privacy obligations. jay cloud’s SAP-native architecture and certified SuccessFactors interface are relevant technical capabilities, but the employer must still validate policies, configuration, and operation.

Build a recording process your teams can use

For mandatory working time recording EU planning, start with local obligations, dependable workforce data, and a process that fits each workplace. Talk to the jay cloud team about HCM-driven time recording for your EU sites.

More from the journal